The Dark Knight Rises: Batman as the Absurd Hero…Almost

Image

With the runaway success of Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight Rises, millions of people were unwittingly exposed to a long standing and particularly relevant philosophical principal; that of the absurd hero. Statistically speaking, if you’ve probably seen The Dark Knight Rises about three to four times at this point. I’m going to go ahead and assume, then, that what little plot spoiling there is to be done will be, for the most part, negligible.

At one point during the film, Bane confronts the physically broken Bruce Wayne in the depths of a prison before he initiates his master plan to destroy Gotham City from the inside. As ALL great villains inevitably do, Bane begins to monologue about how he intends to punish Wayne, as well as the people of Gotham, by leading them to believe that they still have a chance of survival. In other words, allowing them to retain the hope of salvation and watch as their hope is crushed and replaced with despair. This is indeed no new principal, and in fact goes back to the mythic lore of ancient Greece.

Gather ‘round, my children, and listen well to the sorry tale of Old Sisyphus, whom the Gods condemned to a fate worse than death!

Through a singular combination of circumstances which I will here omit for the sake of brevity, Sisyphus, the wisest of mortal men, knew that he was close to death and wanted to give his wife a test of love. He told her to throw his unburied corpse into the public square for all to see. As the story goes, his wife did as she was told, and Sisyphus awoke in the underworld and was angered that his wife cared more about following his orders than about his dignity. Curiously, Sisyphus obtained permission from Pluto, lord of the underworld, to travel back to Earth in order to chastise his wife. When Pluto reached Earth, however, his love of the sparkling sea and the clear sky and the shining sun was reawakened within him. Sisyphus stayed on Earth for many years, truly enjoying the beauty that life had to offer, until his audacity angered the Gods and they threw him back into the depths of the underworld, where his eternal punishment awaited him.

In the underworld, Sisyphus was condemned to roll a boulder up a mountain and upon reaching the precipice, it would roll back down to the bottom. The whole operation was to be repeated for all eternity with no hope of escape.

When we look at Sisyphus’s fate, we no doubt see a tragedy, but it is only a tragedy if Sisyphus believes that he can escape.

Sisyphus’s walk back down the mountain to where his rock lay waiting for him was of particular interest to a philosopher named Albert Camus. He believed that when Sisyphus began to walk back down the mountain again, Sisyphus endured his fate without yielding to it. In other words ABIDED it. Does this sound familiar to anyone?

Let us now return to Bruce Wayne, broken and scared at the bottom of a pit. Bane was right as he stood over the fallen warrior in that hopeless place; he knew that to give the people of Gotham hope of survival while snatching it away at the last moment like a mirage oasis to a lost man in the desert, would be the perfect, soul-crushing finale to Gotham’s demise. Not only was Bane after Gotham’s physical destruction, he also sought the destruction of its collective heart, mind, and soul.

Alas, this is where my carefully constructed comparison breaks down. Bruce Wayne does not give up hope of escape and eventually rebuilds his body as well as his broken psyche. And why is he able to achieve this incredible feat? Because he’s fuckmothering BATMAN, ok? Shut up.

Sorry. Anyway, the point I’m trying to make is that hope is, and forever will be, a powerful and dangerous force. Will you embrace your hopeless, absurd fate and abide it, like Sisyphus? Or will you retain your hope until the bitter end, like the people of Gotham?

Food for thought! 🙂

P.S. I’m in need of some more movies to analyze! Does anyone have any titles that they’d like to see me do? Leave a comment!

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “The Dark Knight Rises: Batman as the Absurd Hero…Almost

  1. drewpan August 21, 2012 / 1:03 am

    Hahaha interesting comparison. However, I see it as “how can we make Bane buy time for Bruce Wayne to rebuild his broken body and return to Gotham?” If you nuke Gotham and destroy/kill everyone in it, is it really necessary to destroy their hope first? What difference would it make unless you intended for survivors?

    • EmanuelVasconcelos August 26, 2012 / 4:09 pm

      The point was that Bane wanted to show Bruce Wayne how he destroyed Gotham in a long period of time so he could see how the people bacame a bunch of savages, losing his hope and humanity in the process, ending everything with a big nuclear bum! In other words, everything was a horror spectacle for Bruce Wayne to see. However the longevity of the spectacle is what backfire Bane’s plan in the end.

  2. Trent Lewin August 21, 2012 / 1:33 am

    Yes, how about Miller’s Crossing?

  3. The Illbomb August 21, 2012 / 10:47 am

    what about the big lebowski on what it makes to be a man, or black swan or any aronofsky film is worth analysing

  4. Yannis Vatis August 29, 2012 / 6:19 am

    I will give you a like for using an allegory of my ancestors. I loved it! I would be curious to see what you have to say about The Matrix – the first movie always! – if you haven’t done so already.

    Heroes like Batman need to have that level of absurdity. It’s one of those elements that make them larger than life. If the hero loses hope and just rots away while the city he protects crumbles and the people he shields wither then why are they heroes? The beauty of fiction is that it breaks the limits of our reality and puts our ethical values into, oftentimes, crazy perspectives.

  5. John S. September 7, 2012 / 9:36 pm

    I;d be interested in your analysis of Modern Times and Downfall.

  6. vaodiva September 10, 2012 / 4:07 pm

    Great writing, great post 🙂
    I do agree with Yannis’ comment, and would like to see you review Matrix

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s